Tuesday, March 10, 2015

Wordpress vs Blogspot Pt 2

I started making notes for this post when I first started blogging on Wordpress in January.  These are some of the differences that seemed major to me at the time, but aren't important anymore, and other things that are still a struggle.

Of course, the main reason I switched from Blogger/Blogspot to Wordpress was because of the comment notification emails being rejected at other blogs, even Blogspot blogs.  Overall, I think Blogger/Blogspot is easier to use and has more built-in features.  There are many things available to Wordpress as plug ins - some free and some not.

So here are the differences I've noticed so far, and not in any particular order.

1.  Blog roll, easier and better at Blogger/Blogspot.  In Blogger, you just add the Blogroll Widget to the sidebar, and add blogs to it by clicking the edit icon under the roll.  In Wordpress, you add the Blogroll Widget to the sidebar with just a few more steps than Blogger, but to add blogs to the roll, you have to go through the dashboard which adds a few more steps.  Also, the name comes up automatically in Blogger once you copy and paste the URL into the widget, but you have to type the name into Wordpress.  The edit icon under the roll in Blogger also makes it easier to make spelling or other small changes.

Once the rolls are up, this is Wordpress, with just the name of the blog:  (And the first one was inserted by Wordpress and can't be removed)

WPBlogRoll1

And this is Blogger/Blogspot, with title of the last blog post, how long ago it was posted, and a snapshot of a photo from that post:

WPBSBlogRoll1

These are the options on Blogspot:  (Wordpress has no options)

WPBSBlogRoll3

p.s.  I could have made a test blog in wordpress, and would if I intended to stay on wordpress, but I needed to try out something quickly and knew how to do it in blogger.  I learned the hard way on blogger that it's better to make changes on a test blog before making changes to the real one.

2.  Scheduled posts, again easier in Blogger/Blogspot.  When making a post in Blogger, the schedule icon is on the right and the post can be scheduled in about three clicks.  There is an easy way to do it in Wordpress, by simply clicking the new post icon in the top right corner of the blog page (looks like a pencil), and then the Schedule post option is on the right and can be done with a single click.  HOWEVER, I did that once and my post disappeared completely.  I consulted the Wordpress support forum and was told that that method (also called the beep beep boop) has a lot of problems and is not recommended for making scheduled posts.  It even has problems with immediate posts but I haven't had any problem with that so far.  Some people have reported that they can't edit a post after using that.  Without going through the new post icon, you have to go through the dashboard to make a new post and then it takes two more clicks to edit publish immediately to another date.  If you use the Add button in the dropdown under My Site on the right side of the blog page, it is the same beep beep boop and the posts have the same problems as using the New Post icon.

Another thing with the scheduled posts, according to the support forum, is that scheduled posts don't appear until someone looks at the blog page.  That causes a problem for people who use readers like Bloglovin because the post doesn't show up at the scheduled time.  I don't go to a reader first, so I've never noticed the lag time.

Edited to add:  I finished this post about 12:30 a.m. on March 10, 2015 and clicked the publish button.  Then I went to bed, and when I got up this morning and checked my blog, it had posted it as if it posted on March 8, buried behind two other posts.  Now I've rescheduled it to post in two minutes, so we'll see what happens.

3.  Editing a published post, much easier in Blogger/Blogspot.  With Blogger, there is an edit button under every post (if you are logged in.  With Wordpress, you have to go through the dropdown under My Site, click on Posts, and then find the post and click edit.  Kind of the long way around for this and most things on Wordpress.

4.  Changing the template, not only much easier on Blogger, but impossible on Wordpress.  On Wordpress, you have to change to a template that has the options you want.  I didn't change my Blogger template often, but I did make changes to it, simple changes like changing the banner size, or the font.  Can't do that on Wordpress.  You can download apps to make some changes I think, but all the ones I wanted had a fee, a small fee, but a fee nonetheless.

5.  Search box.  Automatic on Blogger, but added as a widget on Wordpress.  You can also add it as a widget on Blogger.

6.  Photo storage, a big advantage on Blogger.  At first glance, it would appear that Wordpress is better because it allows 3.0 gb photo storage and Blogger only allows 1.0 gb.  But there is a big but here, so I'll capitalize and bold it.  BUT, blogger uses Picasa Web Albums and doesn't count any photos below 800 x 800 pixels and videos under 15 minutes.   So after being on Wordpress for 68 days, I have used 9 mb of my 3.0 gb storage.  After being on Blogger for seven years and four months posting over 2000 photos and a few videos, I've used 0 mb and 0 gb.  In all fairness, since there is 1000 mb in 1 gb, it would take many years to use that storage, especially if photo size is kept small.

7.  Photo size, another plus for Blogger and negative for Wordpress.  Sometimes I want to make a picture a certain size, even if it distorts it a little.  In Blogger you can do that.  In Wordpress, you can only change a photo by keeping the ratios the same.

8.  Like Button, better on Wordpress, mainly because Blogger doesn't have it.  I think it can be added to Blogger with an outside link like a Pinterest button though.  I don't really know the purpose of the Like button, but people seem to use it.

9.  Comment Emails, a definite plus for Wordpress and not only because of the annoying undelivered emails to Blogger/Blogspot blogs, but because it eliminates a step in replying to comments.  There are some comments, especially those with a question, that need a reply under the comment.  And blog etiquette asks that comments receive an email reply.  Wordpress comment notification emails let you reply to both with a single reply.  Or you can just reply to the blog, or just reply to the person who commented.   The only downside of Wordpress email notifications is that you can't tell who the email is from without opening it.

This is the way the email to a Wordpress blog looks in the inbox:

WPBlogEmails

You can see what post they are commenting on, but not their name.

This is what emails to a Blogger/Blogspot blog look like:

WPBSEmail



I do prefer being able to see who the email is from, but I've gotten used to the Wordpress way and it doesn't bother me anymore.

10.  Backlinks.  I think backlinks are easier in Wordpress, though that is something I've never really cared enough about to learn how it really works on either format.

11.  Stats.  I prefer Google stats over Wordpress stats.   I like being able to see the total number of views for each post.  Here is the admin page for posts in Blogger/Blogspot, which shows the total views for each post and the total number of comments:

WPBSPostPage



And here is the admin page for posts in Wordpress which shows the number of comments and the number of likes for each post:

WPPostPg

(I hope these screen shots aren't as blurry when this is posted as they are in the draft version.)

On the stats page, I think Wordpress is ahead in that it tells all the pages that were visited today and how many unique visitors.  Blogger tells how many page views, but doesn't tell which pages were visited.  But, it shows which posts are most popular and that is a plus also.

12.  HTML codes.  I prefer Blogger/Blogspot here too.  When writing a post in Blogger, you have the choice of "Compose" or "Html".  Compose creates the post as if it were written on an internet forum or Microsoft Word, which is great for people who want to see what the post will look like as they write it.  Html lets you use code to create the page, which gives you more options than the Compose tab. When writing a post in Wordpress, you have the choice of "Visual" or "Text".  Visual is like Compose; it looks like the finished post.  Text is a lot like Html except not all html will work in it.  Font color and size, for example, has to be written with span tags, not just the regular font color html.  Also, when you write the post in Visual and then switch to Text, it will add so much code that it's hard to read - at least for me.

13.  Logging in is also much easier in Blogger/Blogspot.  With a Wordpress blog, you have to leave you blog page and go to wordpress.com to sign in.  With Blogger, the sign in link is in the top corner of every page.  The downside of that is that Google owns so many websites now and wants everyone to use just one log in name on everything.  I had a Youtube account with a different email before it was Google owned and now it seems that the videos I loaded with that account are gone or at least not accessible.  It's also kind of a hassle to have separate blog accounts with Google too since they push that One Account thing.

Another big downside to Blogger/Blogspot is Google+.  I really, really, really don't like Google+ but I keep finding myself part of it.   I've deleted my Google+ profile three times this week.  I don't know if I am automatically added to it when I read an email from a Google+ member or if it's from logging onto Youtube.  But it's annoying.

............

That's all I can think of at this time.  If you know of other differences that new bloggers to either format might want to know before they make the switch, please post in the comments.

............

I had intended to give Wordpress a full three months before making up my mind whether I liked it or not.  And I do like it, but not enough to leave Blogger/Blogspot behind.  For one thing, I have so much content on my Blogspot blog that it comes up in most searches.  Call me shallow, but I like searching for an image and seeing my stuff near the top.

I know blog content can be migrated  to other blogs, but I'm afraid migrating my Wordpress posts over to my old Blogspot blog will mess up my Blogspot blog.  So what I'm going to do is repost the Wordpress posts over there.  When that is finished, I will change the blog name (another thing I really like about my Wordpress blog - that has nothing to do with Wordpress), and end this blog.  I'll just have to visit the Comment section of the Dashboard to see who is commenting.  I won't be able to send an email reply, but I can reply on my blog and comment on your blogs, which I like to do anyway.  I think anyone who takes the time to comment should get a comment from me too.

So while it's been fun, I'm going to bid Wordpress adieu.

4 comments:

Life in Pieces said...

That's a nice summary of the differences. Now I'm glad I picked Blogger when I started.

Nancy said...

I finally figured out a way to comment without having them bounce back to me. It worked yesterday, so my fingers are crossed that it will continue to work. it took some tinkering and cursing and near tears, but hopefully I got it fixed.

martidiy said...

I am too, though I'm glad I tested the waters at Wordpress.

martidiy said...

Please share your secret!!! That's the one drawback about moving back to blogspot for me.